Electric vehicles and hybrids will be equipped with noise-making devices

The rise of hybrid and electric cars has drawn concern from some groups which fears blind and visually-impaired pedestrians won't be aware of oncoming cars without familiar engine noises.Thus, electric vehicles and hybrids will be equipped with noise-making devices to alert blind or unaware pedestrians to their approach.

2/16/15 4:00 am chumakdenis 1

Part of the appeal of hybrid and electric cars is their quiet operation, but regulators fear this also poses a danger to pedestrians.

That's led to several attempts to equip new hybrids and electric cars with noise-making devices, to alert blind or unaware pedestrians to their approach.

3083.jpg

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

As a result of lobbying by the National Federation for the Blind, the Pedestrian Safety Enhancement Act was signed into law in 2011 to do just that.

But implementation has apparently stalled: The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) has pushed back the date for a final ruling on the proposed noisemaker standards until the end of the year, according to Wards Auto.

That means the new rule won't be implemented until 2018.

More debates?

The latest delay further lengthens a debate that's been going on almost since the first hybrids were launched in the U.S. 15 years ago.

The rise of hybrid and electric cars has drawn concern from some groups(particularly the Federation), which fears blind and visually-impaired pedestrians won't be aware of oncoming cars without engine noises.

Publicity over the issue led the NHTSA to convene a conference in 2008, and to conduct two subsequent studies.

Electric vehicles and hybrids are more dangerous for pedestrians than vehicles with internal-combustion engines

One 2009 study found that hybrids and electric cars were twice as likely as conventional internal-combustion cars to be involved in a pedestrian collision, while a 2011 NHTSA study estimated the chances of a pedestrian collision to be 35 percent higher.

However, there was relatively little data for researchers to work with.

The 2009 study only included data from 12 states, and was limited to injuries from 2000 - when there were very few hybrids on the road and around 10 years before the current generation of electric cars went on sale.

Nonetheless, the Pedestrian Safety Enhancement Act was signed into law, and the NHTSA is still trying to implement it.

Not everyone thinks the same way

Carmakers have criticized the agency's proposed rules - saying the sounds would be too loud - and it would likely require the devices to be fitted to the quietest of cars, not solely those with electric or hybrid powertrains.

Some hybrid and electric vehicle owners reportedly oppose such devices as well, because they enjoy the silent operation of their cars.

Still, in anticipation of the standards, many electric-car makers have already provided an alert noise as a standard feature.

Automatic chirping noise

3086.jpg3085.jpg3087.jpg

 

 

 

 


The Nissan Leaf is equipped with an automatic chirping noise below 18 mph, while the Chevrolet Volt  and Spark EV have alert sounds that can be actuated by the driver as needed.

Some other carmakers are waiting until the law takes effect to add noisemakers to their vehicles, but it is starting to look like there may not be a lot of hurrying required.

*What do you think about these new laws? Do you agree or disagree? Why?

Please share your opinion with us in the comment section below.

  electric vehicle all-electric vehicle safety measures noise-making devices national federation for the blind the pedestrian safety enhancement act the national highway traffic safety administration nhtsa innovations

You must be logged in to comment!